Choosing a donor is one of the most personal decisions in fertility treatment. Donor profiles can list dozens of details, from eye colour to education, and it’s hard to know where to start. So we asked our patients what actually mattered to them.
What we did
In August 2025 we interviewed eight former patients who had treatment in our donor programme, with donor eggs or donor sperm: five heterosexual couples, a same-sex female couple and two single women. Each conversation was recorded and transcribed, and two researchers analysed them independently.
What we found
- Looking alike came first, for everyone. All eight wanted a donor who resembled them. For most (five of the eight), it was about their child feeling they “fit in” with the family.
- Other details came second. Personality, health and education were discussed, but after appearance.
- Ethnicity mattered, in different ways. Two people couldn’t find a donor of their own ethnic background, because ethnicity filters were too broad and there are fewer donors from non-white backgrounds. One turned down a donor who matched on appearance, because of tensions between ethnic groups. Two said ethnicity didn’t matter to them as long as the donor looked like them.
- Choosing was quicker than people expected. With digital donor profiles, half chose a donor within 24 hours. Some found AI-assisted matching efficient and reassuring; others wanted a person to check the match too.
- People wanted more medical background. Two said donor family medical histories were too limited.
Why it matters
Many of these preferences are never said out loud, so clinics can miss them. The study points to practical changes: recording ethnicity-related preferences clearly from the start, recruiting donors from a wider range of backgrounds, and keeping a person involved alongside AI matching.
What this means for you
- It’s normal for looking alike to be your top priority, and it’s fine to say so. Tell your donor coordinator exactly what matters to you, including ethnicity and background, even if it feels awkward.
- If a filter doesn’t describe your background well, ask. A coordinator can search more precisely than a tick box.
- Ask what family medical history is available before you decide.
- Take the time you need. Some people choose in a day; others take longer.
Donor treatment at Avenues
We search five partner egg banks for a donor who fits what matters to you, with AI-supported donor matching and a dedicated donor coordinator. IVF / ICSI with 6 donor eggs starts from £14,349. See donor egg treatment →
Using donor sperm? Fair IVF Donor is £4,649 with a vial of donor sperm included, for those who meet the Fair IVF criteria.
Not sure where to start? Book a free 15-minute call with our team.
Based on our research abstracts “Resemblance primarily drives egg-donor choice, but ethnicity always shapes decisions” and “Selecting donors in the digital age: patient perspectives from an AI-enabled gamete programme” (Avenues).
Your questions, answered
What matters most when choosing an egg donor?
In our interviews with former donor patients, every one of them put looking alike first, often so their child would feel they fit in with the family. Personality, health and education mattered too, but came second.
Can I choose a donor from my own ethnic background?
You can ask for it, and it’s worth saying early. There are fewer donors from some backgrounds, so tell your donor coordinator what matters to you. At Avenues we search five partner egg banks to widen the choice.
How long does it take to choose a donor?
It varies. In our study, half of patients chose a donor within 24 hours using digital donor profiles, but there’s no rush. Take the time you need.

